In short

A sample approval process is the controlled sequence in which buyer and supplier accept a physical sample, a dimensioned drawing and a photographic record, then use all three as the acceptance standard for bulk production. It ends with a signed record, not with a sample on a table.

Factories in Foshan make samples constantly, for several buyers, in the same week. The sample is rarely the problem. What travels with it is: a photograph with no date, a drawing with no revision, a colour approved under office lighting that will live beside a window. Weeks later the container arrives and the argument is about memory.

01A sample approval process fixes a specification, not a look

Approval is a decision about a specification, and a specification carries more parts than a photograph can show. A bedside table has a substrate, an edge band, a veneer, a stain, a topcoat, a handle, a hinge and a carton. Each is a separate line on the record.

Six sample types, what each one proves, and the decision it can support
Record What it proves What it cannot prove
Showroom sampleA shape and a finish exist in the catalogueThat your order runs on the same line, from the same batch
Lab dip or drawdownA colour reached on a named substrate with a named topcoatHow it ages, or how it reads in your room
First-off (prototype)The drawing can be built with the tooling on siteThat the jig holds across a run of forty
Golden sampleBoth sides accepted this unit, sealed and datedThat the factory still holds the material in six weeks
Pre-production sampleThe first unit off the line matches the golden sampleAnything about units two to two hundred
Retention sampleWhat shipped, kept for comparisonThat the next order will match it

Names vary between factories. Define them in the purchase order.

A buyer who approved a showroom sample has approved a look. A buyer who sealed a golden sample beside a signed drawing has approved a product.

Decision rule: one approval per finish combination. A walnut bed and a walnut wardrobe in one room are two approvals, because two factories, two topcoats and two cure cycles are involved.

02The golden sample is sealed, labelled and dated

The golden sample is the unit both sides accept as the reference, sealed so that neither can quietly alter it. Its authority comes from the seal, the label and the signature, not from the object.

Seal three sets from the same run: one with the buyer, one in the factory's sample room, one with the inspector. Wrap upholstery and stained timber away from daylight. A sample left in a south-facing window yellows in a season, then fails the bulk for a reason production never caused.

Three sets, one seal number, two signatures on the label. If the factory's copy and yours carry different numbers, the record is void and the sample is a display piece.

Decision rule: the purchase order cites the seal number and the revision letter in the specification line. An inspector who cannot match both numbers stops before the cartons are opened.

Catalogue reference: furniture and fitted living — models, dimensions and finishes for the directions discussed above.

03The drawing carries the dimensions the sample cannot

A sample shows a 20 mm overhang. Only a drawing says 20 ±0.5 mm, and only a drawing says which face the tolerance applies to.

A usable set carries the general arrangement, carcass sections, door and drawer gaps, the edge detail, a hardware schedule with model numbers, the substrate and the finish schedule. Twelve sheets is ordinary for a wardrobe run; one elevation is not a drawing, and a factory that receives one builds what it usually builds.

ISO 2768-1 general tolerances, medium class (m), for linear dimensions without an individual tolerance (millimetres)
Dimension range Permitted deviation
0.5 to 3±0.1
Over 3 to 6±0.1
Over 6 to 30±0.2
Over 30 to 120±0.3
Over 120 to 400±0.5
Over 400 to 1,000±0.8
Over 1,000 to 2,000±1.2
Over 2,000 to 4,000±2

A timber carcass will not hold ±1.2 mm over 1,000 mm once it acclimatises to a dry room. Mark the critical dimensions and give the rest a wider class you have stated.

A revision letter is not administration. Approve revision C, receive goods built to B, and every dimension you checked is void, often by 3 mm at a door gap, which separates a door that closes from one that rubs. Keep a one-page register: revision, date, change, approver.

Decision rule: approval binds one revision only. A change to a dimension, a material or a hardware model increments the letter and returns the record to unsigned.

04Colour, fabric and finish need their own gates

One signature cannot approve a stain, a fabric and a powder coat. Each is a separate reference with a separate failure, and each fails in a different season.

The common failure is the topcoat. A sample sealed under a matte lacquer and bulk finished in satin reads as a different colour beside a window, and both are honestly called the approved stain. Approve the sheen, not only the pigment.

Decision rule: every finish on the drawing schedule gets its own reference number, photograph and signature, and the number appears on the order.

05The photo log is evidence only if it is repeatable

A photograph proves what the lens was pointed at, on one day, under one light. That is enough to show a missing handle. It is not enough to show a colour shift of two units.

  1. Fix the views: front, back, both sides, top, underside, the open joint and the label. Eight frames per item.
  2. Put a 300 mm scale rule in every frame, along the edge being measured.
  3. Put a grey card in the first frame of each set, so white balance can be corrected later.
  4. Light at 45° and shoot square-on; a flash on axis flattens the texture you are recording.
  5. Keep one camera and lens for the order. A phone upgrade mid-order breaks the comparison.
  6. Name files YYYY-MM-DD_item_revision_view, so a missing view is visible at a glance.
  7. Upload the same day. A log written from memory at month end is a story.

What a photo cannot show: 0.2 mm of lippage, gloss, foam density, smell, packed weight. Those need a straight edge, a gloss meter, a hand or a laboratory, and pretending otherwise is how a defect is found at installation.

Decision rule: eight views, one scale rule, one grey card. A supplier set with fewer is not an approved sample; it is an unphotographed one.

06Sequence the gates so nothing is made twice

Each gate releases money and material. Run them in order and the cost of a mistake stays inside a sample; skip one and the discovery moves into the container.

Five approval gates, the record signed at each, and what the signature releases
Gate Record signed What it releases
1 DrawingDrawing at a stated revision, signed and datedMaterial order and the cutting list
2 FinishLab dip, drawdown or chip with a reference numberFinish and topcoat order
3 First-offPrototype with measured dimensions recordedJigs, templates and tooling
4 Golden sampleSealed sample, label and eight-view photo logBulk production
5 InspectionReport measured against the sealed sampleBalance payment and the shipping booking

Five gates, and each one costs calendar time. That time belongs in the schedule you give your client.

The order matters because later gates cannot repair earlier ones. Approving the finish after the first-off means refinishing the prototype. Approving the drawing after the golden sample means rebuilding the sample, and the rebuilt version is the one that gets remembered.

Decision rule: no gate opens on a verbal yes. A gate opens when the record is signed, and the record names the person who signed it.

07Write the approval into the PO so a remake has an owner

A record has force only where the purchase order says what happens when bulk departs from it.

Put the balance against the record. A 30% deposit with 70% before shipment by T/T is the common structure; a letter of credit moves the risk to documents and adds a discrepancy to manage. Either way the trigger is a passed inspection, not a ship date the factory chose.

State the remedy in days and money: rework before shipment, replacement on the next order, or a credit. 'Quality to be agreed' agrees nothing, and it will be agreed by whoever holds the container.

Decision rule: if the order cannot name the seal number, the revision letter and the inspection standard, the approval record is a folder rather than a contract, and a remake has no owner.

What your RFQ should state

  1. The golden sample seal number and the drawing revision letter, both cited in the purchase order.
  2. Three sealed sets from one production run: buyer, factory and inspector.
  3. A drawing set with dimensions, carcass sections, door and drawer gaps, edge details and hardware model numbers.
  4. A stated tolerance for each critical dimension, and a named general class for the rest.
  5. Finish references by number: fabric article, stain code, topcoat and sheen, powder coat RAL and gloss at 60°.
  6. Eight photo views per item, with a 300 mm scale rule and a grey card in the first frame.
  7. The five approval gates, with the name of the person who signs each one off.
  8. The ISO 2859-1 inspection level, the AQL for major and minor defects, and the remedy for non-conforming bulk.

Where this guidance stops

Questions buyers ask

What is a golden sample in a sample approval process?

It is the unit both sides accept as the physical reference for a specification, sealed and labelled so neither can alter it afterwards. It settles arguments about finish, colour, feel and workmanship. It does not settle dimensions on its own, because a sample cannot state a tolerance; that is the signed drawing's job.

How many sealed samples should I keep?

Three: one with the buyer, one in the factory sample room, one with the inspector. All three come from the same run and carry the same seal number. Two is workable if the inspector photographs against the buyer's set, but a factory with no sealed copy will rebuild from memory once the buyer's set is abroad.

Can a photograph replace a physical sample?

No. A photograph records what the lens saw under one light on one day, and it cannot carry gloss, texture, weight or foam firmness. It is a supporting record that shows a missing handle or a changed seam. Keep the sealed sample and use the photo log to prove which views were checked.

What should the sample approval record contain?

The item and purchase order numbers, the drawing revision letter, the seal number, the number of sealed sets, the finish references, the approval date and the signature of the person accepting it. Add the photo log reference. If any of those is missing, the record cannot be matched to bulk production weeks later.

Who should sign the approval?

One named person on each side, with authority to accept the cost of a change. A signature from a salesperson who cannot release production is a courtesy, not an approval. Put the name on the label and on the drawing, because staff move and the successor inherits the file, not the conversation.

What if bulk production does not match the approved sample?

The purchase order should already say: rework or replacement at the supplier's cost before shipment, or a credit. The inspection report measures bulk against the sealed sample and the signed drawing, and the balance is held until it passes. Without that clause the remedy is a negotiation conducted while the container waits.

Is sample approval the same as pre-shipment inspection?

No. Approval fixes the standard; inspection measures production against it later. Inspection under ISO 2859-1 samples a lot and applies an AQL, so it estimates conformity rather than proving it, and a visual inspection cannot confirm material composition or hidden performance.

Sources

  1. Incoterms 2020 rules — International Chamber of Commerce
  2. UCP 600 and letters of credit — International Chamber of Commerce
  3. ISO 2859-1 — Sampling procedures for inspection by attributes, Part 1: schemes indexed by AQL — International Organization for Standardization
  4. ISO 2768-1 — General tolerances: linear and angular dimensions without individual tolerance indications — International Organization for Standardization
  5. ISO 105-J03 — Textiles: tests for colour fastness, calculation of colour differences — International Organization for Standardization
  6. National Enterprise Credit Information Publicity System — State Administration for Market Regulation, China
  7. Basic importing and exporting — US Customs and Border Protection
  8. ISO 9001:2015 — Quality management systems: requirements — International Organization for Standardization

Pages related to this guide

How this guide was checked

FS

Foshan Supply editorial team · Catalogue indexMethodology

Written in Foshan and reviewed against the catalogue and public standards on 2026-11-05. This page is a buying guide, not a quotation or a warranty. How we work.

How to cite this page: Foshan Supply, “Sample approval process: the record that stops a remake”, 2026-11-05, https://foshansupply.com/blog/sample-approval-process/